Air yards, or average depth of target (ADOT), measure how far downfield a pass travels beyond the line of scrimmage, excluding yards after the catch. They're a hot topic again, and we have one person to thank: Bo Nix.
Through Week 9, Nix has the shortest passes in the league, 5.6 air yards per throw. If that holds, he would finish with the shortest season of any starter since David Carr in 2006. His passing chart is peppered around the line of scrimmage, and even his big plays are often glorified dump-offs. Ryan Fitzpatrick called Nix's play "almost disrespectful to the quarterback position." Yet, thanks to an excellent defense and a knack for winning one-score games, Nix and Denver have not paid much of a price for their unsustainable play style.
Or maybe it's not Nix's fault that we're talking about ADOT. In fact, maybe it's YOUR fault for talking about something so silly. Air yards are about style points. Who cares how far the ball travels if you're scoring, protecting the football, and winning games? Denver is doing all three. Just look at Drew Brees. A potent offense doesn't need to push the ball downfield, and perhaps Denver's short-passing approach is exactly what allows its defense to thrive.
So who's right here: Dr. Jekyll or Mr. High-ADOT? I dug into the numbers to find out if air yards mean a damn thing.
Do more air yards mean a better offense?
The figure plots air yards (measured several different ways) on the horizontal axis against offensive performance (also measured several ways) on the vertical axis. You can also use the middle dropdown to look at various situations.
The goal is to see how much of offensive quality can be explained simply by passing depth. The answer? Almost none. Plot air yards per attempt against virtually any measure of offensive performance, and you'll find little to no correlation. How far a quarterback throws the ball tells you remarkably little about how good an offense is. Great offenses throw short, bad offenses throw deep, and vice versa.
But play around with the measures, and you might find an exception: a way in which passing depth actually does tell us something about offensive quality.



